What Google Changed to Close a CNIL Injunction
ON THIS PAGE
Google made its advertising-cookie disclosures clearer during account creation. It also redesigned its Gmail advertisements.
CNIL accepted the changes made by Google for the purposes of the injunction. However, it still questioned the clarity of Google's registration process.
The account-creation screens originally examined by the authority featured wording like “if you accept” when introducing advertising-cookie information, even though users had no option to reject all advertising cookies and still open an account.
Users could still refuse personalised advertising, but according to CNIL, Google did not clearly explain what would happen after that refusal.
What the 2025 Injunction Required
CNIL adopted SAN-2025-004 on 1 September 2025 and announced it two days later. It fined GOOGLE LLC €200 million and GOOGLE IRELAND LIMITED €125 million for two practices:
- advertising cookies during account creation. Google's registration process breached Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act, which covers storing information on or accessing information from users' devices. Until a change in October 2023, refusing personalised advertising had also been harder than accepting it.
- Email-like Gmail advertisements. Ads that resembled received messages amounted to electronic commercial prospecting without prior consent under Article L.34-5 of the French Postal and Electronic Communications Code.
For users in France, Google had to make the advertising-cookie condition clear during registration and obtain prior consent for Gmail ads in the email-like format. It had six months from notification to comply. A delay could have triggered a penalty of €100,000 a day for each company.
The findings concerned two French eprivacy provisions. GDPR standards were also relevant to whether consent was valid.
What Google Changed During Account Creation
The closure decision examined Google's revised one-step and four-step registration flows. The changes covered both the information shown to users and the wording of their choices:
- The cookie condition appeared earlier. On the screen where users chose a registration route, Google explained that advertising helped keep most services free and that account creation required cookies and similar technologies, including for advertising. Before this change, users had to piece together the condition from separate screens. In the four-step route, the advertising choice still came before the final confirmation connecting it to cookies.
- Refusing personalisation was explained. The one-step route told users that they would still see generic ads chosen using contextual factors. In Google's setup, cookies continued to support ad delivery and measurement whether ads were personalised or generic. Refusing personalisation changed how the ads were selected, not whether those cookies operated.
- The options were presented more evenly. Google added information about generic ads to a settings screen that had previously focused on personalisation. In the four-step route, a heading encouraging personalised ads was replaced with, translated from French, “To control ads, select your advertising experience”. CNIL noted the more balanced wording.
This distinction concerns Google's setup. Contextual ads do not inherently need Tracking Cookies, although the technology used to deliver or measure them may require consent.
How Gmail's Redesign Changed the Legal Analysis
Gmail's original promotions appeared among private messages in the Promotions and Social tabs. They looked like received emails. CNIL relied on the CJEU's judgment of 25 November 2021 in Case C-102/20, which addressed this kind of inbox advertising. Changes made in April 2023 had not made the ads sufficiently distinct.
The later redesign separated ads from the message list:
- Placement: Ads stayed fixed at the bottom of the tabs while emails scrolled.
- Appearance: A different colour set them apart, with an advertising label in the position normally used for the sender's name.
- Dismissal: Users could click an icon on the web or swipe the ad away on mobile.
- Reappearance: A dismissed ad was not replaced during the session. New ads appeared only after users reconnected.
CNIL found that these ads were clearly distinguishable from received emails. The specific prior-consent requirement it had identified under Article L.34-5 therefore no longer applied to this format. That finding does not cover every form of inbox advertising, and cookie or personal-data rules still apply separately.
Why CNIL Closed the Order but Still Questioned Registration
In SAN-2026-014, adopted on 23 September and announced on 14 October 2026, CNIL confirmed that Google had met the deadline. It did not impose the conditional €100,000-a-day penalty on either company. The separate €325 million fines were unaffected, and the decision did not resolve any appeal against them.
CNIL still pointed to problems with the way users were presented with choices:
- More screens: The one-step route had grown from two screens to four, scattering relevant information among other explanations.
- An unclear “Reject all” button: Its scope was hard to understand because it covered web activity, YouTube history and personalised advertising settings.
- No direct choice of generic ads: Users reached that option by refusing personalisation.
- Late explanations: In both routes, detailed cookie-purpose information appeared after users had already made related choices.
CNIL did not treat those observations as new infringements, but it left open the possibility of further investigations. It also did not decide whether the full registration process met every requirement of Article 82.
Closing this injunction was not a general approval of cookie walls, where access depends on accepting trackers. CNIL's guidance calls for assessment case by case, including the alternatives available and whether consent is freely given. The European Data Protection Board's Opinion 08/2024 addresses “consent or pay” models at large online platforms; it does not automatically apply to every website. Financing a free service with advertising does not, by itself, make advertising cookies strictly necessary.
What You Should Review in Your Consent Setup
A cookie banner is only one part of registration. Review the screens, choices and tracking behaviour together:
- Map registration screens in the order visitors see them, including mobile and alternative routes.
- List cookies, other storage and trackers, recording their providers and purposes.
- Separate personalised from contextual advertising, including the tools used for delivery and measurement.
- Review conditions for access and any alternatives offered to visitors.
- Show the purpose of a choice before someone is asked to make it.
- Check what each control changes, especially a button labelled “Reject all”.
- Check promotions inside messaging interfaces for email-like appearance and direct-marketing requirements.
- Cut unnecessary registration screens and separate unrelated privacy settings.
- Record fixes, assign owners and repeat tests after interface or vendor changes.
To see whether consent choices work as described, test the registration process in this order:
- First visit: Use a browser without stored preferences. Follow each advertising option and record what appears before the choice, not only on the confirmation screen.
- Return visit: Change an existing preference, then withdraw consent. Repeat for the relevant regional configurations.
- Browser check: Inspect cookies, storage, tag activity and network requests before a choice, after it and after withdrawal. A recorded refusal should match what the browser actually loads and sends.
How a CMP Can Support Advertising-Cookie Consent
A Consent Management Platform (CMP) can help a website put visitors’ advertising choices into effect across cookies, scripts and measurement tags. The capabilities most relevant to the issues in the Google decision are:
- Automatic script blocking helps keep advertising and measurement scripts inactive when consent is required but has not been given. Third-party cookie blocking adds controls for third-party technologies, though server-set cookies and other requests may need separate handling. Scripts managed through Google Tag Manager need consent controls configured and tested in GTM, rather than relying on automatic script blocking.
- Cookie Scanner helps identify cookies and related technologies used for advertising, delivery and measurement. Automatic monthly scans can reveal new trackers after site or vendor changes if the feature is enabled.
- User consents recording keeps a record of visitors’ decisions when enabled, including changes to their preferences and consent withdrawal.
- Consent events help tags respond when visitors change their choices. Google Tag Manager integration can help coordinate those signals across advertising and measurement tags.
Other ways CMPs can help include:
- Geo targeting supports different consent-banner configurations by visitor location. A detected location does not necessarily establish legal residence.
- Global privacy regulation support can support region-specific consent and objection controls. For applicable US rules, check that opt-out choices and Global Privacy Control signals work as expected.
Some CMPs also support Google Consent Mode v2. In Basic Consent Mode, Google tags wait until consent is granted. In Advanced mode, tags may load with consent denied and send cookieless pings. A CMP also cannot determine whether conditional access is lawful or whether an inbox advertisement requires prior consent.
CookieScript, a CMP, appears on Google’s list of partners available for Consent Mode setup. It is also a Google-certified CMP and received Gold tier status in Google’s CMP tiering system.
Compare CMP prices and features side by side
Pick up to 4 consent platforms, set your number of websites and see yearly prices, pageview limits and features in one view.
- Yearly prices for 1 to 200 domains
- Pageview limits and extra fees
- Features and customer reviews